Trouble at the top: Infighting among school board members invites outside criticism

Date:

Share post:

In a series of public blows to Michigan State University’s leadership since the Larry Nassar scandal prompted longtime president Lou Anna Simon to resign, the prominent research university has turned over five presidents in five years. Now, on the heels of another sexual harassment case with former head football coach Mel Tucker, MSU is seeking the resignation of an individual above the president: Board of Trustees Chair Rema Vassar.

In a seven-page letter obtained by MSU’s student newspaper, The State News, trustee member Brianna Scott outlined 10 violations committed by Vassar since January 2023, which she believes is worthy evidence for Vassar’s ousting. Scott prefaced the letter by illuminating Vassar’s perpetual patterns of bullying, carrying personal agendas and acting vindictive toward members who opposed her.

“It is with that responsibility in mind that I am calling for Dr. Vassar to resign from the Board of Trustees,” Scott wrote. “If she chooses not to do so, I call upon my fellow trustees to remove her as Chair and to refer her to the Governor for removal pursuant to MCL 168.293.”

When the board discovered that a particular member had publicly leaked the name of the woman who accused Mel Tucker of sexual harassment, Scott accused Vassar of not complying with a forensic review of her telephone. Additionally, Vassar placed a “heart” on a text message with a former board member who engaged in victim blaming and minimizing the claimant’s trauma, Scott wrote. In the same text exchange, she found Vassar guilty of planning to leverage the scandal to oust current interim president Teresa Woodruff.


More from UB: Higher ed, K12 and edtech giants join forces in next big step for micro-credentials


Members speak out

Since Scott’s public decry of Vassar, university and community leaders have spoken up.

MSU Trustee Dan Kelly, chair of the board’s audit, risk and compliance committee, said the university’s general counsel’s office initiated an investigation into the matter, WKAR reports. Trustee Dianne Byrum and Faculty Senate Chair Jack Lipton have also called for Vassar’s resignation. Outside of the university, Sen. Debbie Stabenow has urged a change in leadership. Gov. Gretchen Whitmer is also reviewing the matter and stated she will not withhold her power to remove a public board member if they display gross negligence, the Detroit Free Press reports.

However, trustee Dennis Denno is in support of Vassar. “I support Chair Rema Vassar, and I’m disappointed some Trustees are grandstanding with false accusations due to a personal grievance,” he said in a statement to The State News.

 

Alcino Donadel
Alcino Donadel
Alcino Donadel is editor at University Business covering college leadership, enrollment, and career readiness since 2023. He is a first-generation journalism graduate from the University of Florida with triple citizenship from the U.S., Ecuador, and Brazil. Find Alcino on LinkedIn or email him at [email protected].

The Always-On Insight and Networking Platform for Superintendents and Their Teams

AI-driven insights peer-to-peer collaboration and more build exclusively fot K-12 Superintendents and thier leaders
Built for the uniqueness of the superintendent role and their supporting team.Most platforms treat all K–12 leaders the same. DA+ recognizes that superintendents face a unique level of pressure, complexity, visibility, and responsibility—and gives them a space designed specifically for the demands of the top job.
A community where you don’t have to explain the context.Skip the backstory. DA+ understands the job, the politics, the stakes, and the pace.
Your decisions shape communities.Find the tools and peer insight to make them with confidence here.
Leadership tailored to the realities of running a district.From board relations to budgets, crisis response to community trust—DA+ focuses on the challenges only superintendents navigate each day.
Built for superintendents.Powered by superintendents. Trusted by superintendents. If you run a district, you belong here.

Related Articles